Thanksgiving Leftovers: You Brought a Side. Can You Take the Turkey?
Thanksgiving leftovers: Is it rude to bring your own containers? You brought the pumpkin pie, but does that entitle you to tomorrow’s lunch?
At Sylvia’s family Thanksgiving dinner, bringing containers is almost a requirement. At Nancy’s, showing up with an empty Cool Whip tub is the height of tackiness. Same holiday. Very different family stories and exit strategies.
Before you head to your in-laws’ house or Friendsgiving, join Nancy May and Sylvia France on Family Food Stories for a food fight over Thanksgiving leftovers, what counts as appropriate manners, family traditions, and who gets custody of the stuffing.
With Friendsgiving at Nancy’s house coming up, this argument is personal. Sylvia believes sending guests home with food is part of feeding them. Nancy says the host should offer first. Where does generosity end and meal-prepping at somebody else’s house begin?
The debate comes with a few things worth bringing to your own table: the history of doggy bags and their convenient canine excuse, wishbone traditions, and a leftovers cookbook that raises serious questions about what people once considered dinner.
Then there’s Sylvia’s Cuban Thanksgiving in West Tampa. She stopped the turkey bones from going into the trash but walked out without the homemade sangria recipe. She’s been trying to recreate the drink. The bones were easier to secure.
You’ll learn how to navigate holiday hosting customs, make good use of leftover turkey, and plan to get food home safely. But before anyone clears the table, there’s another question worth asking.
You know how Grandma’s stuffing tastes. Do you know who taught her to make it? Save that story and recipe in your own book here.
We share a simple way to ask for a family recipe, and capture the cook’s story while they’re there to explain what “a little of this” actually means. That’s something worth taking home, whatever your position on plastic containers.
Five things you’ll take away
- How to ask for Thanksgiving leftovers gracefully. Check with your host before bringing containers, and make your plans clear if you’re hosting.
- How to handle different family food traditions. Avoid assuming that the rules at your childhood table apply at your in-laws’ or Friendsgiving.
- The history behind doggy bags and wishbones. Bring a conversation starter besides “Who made the cranberry sauce?”
- How to make the most of leftover turkey. Think beyond sandwiches to soup and broth, with practical storage and travel tips.
- How to preserve a family recipe and its story. Ask who taught the cook, write down their name, and find out why the dish returns every holiday.
Listen before you pack the containers. Follow Family Food Stories on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and share this episode with whoever’s hosting. Then tell us at FamilyFoodStories.com: Do you wait to be offered Thanksgiving leftovers, or arrive with your containers ready?
Question:
In your family, do you wait to be offered leftovers, or do you arrive with a perfectly matched set of your own plastic containers, ready to load up and take home after dinner?
Sylvia France:
In my family, people show up to Thanksgiving with a dish to share and their
Sylvia France:
own containers for leftovers.. So when a father of one of my kid's friends came over to a cookout
Sylvia France:
in Omaha, he said the watermelon was the best he ever had.
Sylvia France:
So of course, I had plenty.
Sylvia France:
I made extra, and I gave him what was left, and he actually looked at
Sylvia France:
me like I had eight eyeballs, and he asked me, "What is this for?"
Nancy May:
I can see the look on this guy's face right now.
Sylvia France:
He was Mr. Harvard, but I was like, "I, you
Sylvia France:
know, if you like it and I have plenty, I s- you share it." That's just how I grew up
Nancy May:
Well, that was very nice of you, but I get New
Nancy May:
England tradition and I get stodgy Boston, believe me.
Nancy May:
Still, if it's a Harvard man, even worse.
Nancy May:
But at my house, nothing goes home unless we plan for it, and
Nancy May:
, well, maybe you ask, but if you did ask, it's only afterwards.
Nancy May:
Beforehand, déclassé, darling.
Nancy May:
Walk in carrying containers for leftovers and you're asked to go
Sylvia France:
In my family, that's expected.
Sylvia France:
We call it, eh, a Southern thing
Nancy May:
Well, I guess I gotta get my Southern jive
Nancy May:
on because I haven't gotten it there just quite yet.
Nancy May:
I still have too much New England roots in me.
Nancy May:
But people used to need a doggy bag for this back when doggy bags were, well, new.
Nancy May:
The polite way to carry food out of a restaurant was to say, "I need something for the dog, darling."
Sylvia France:
Even if they didn't have one?
Nancy May:
Yes.
Nancy May:
You know, a lot of those sneaky Petes, as we call them,
Nancy May:
didn't have dogs, even the cute ones that fit in your pockets
Sylvia France:
We're eating Thanksgiving at your house this
Sylvia France:
year, and I've got a question about that, and you have not heard it
Nancy May:
Uh-oh, I am afraid.
Nancy May:
I am very afraid.
Sylvia France:
You should be.
Sylvia France:
Nancy gets it before the break, and you get the one leftover you should never leave a table without
Nancy May:
Ooh, this is gonna be a good one.
Nancy May:
But before we start, I am Nancy May,
Sylvia France:
And I'm Sylvia France, and this is Family Food Stories, the award-winning show
Sylvia France:
about the food on your table and the people it came from
Nancy May:
And today we're doing a toast like we always do, toasting with wine for Thanksgiving dinner.
Nancy May:
Of course, that's coming up around the corner.
Nancy May:
So there's a glass in my hand, like there wouldn't be otherwise.
Nancy May:
And this one is from the Brotherhood Winery,- the
Nancy May:
winery in New York that sold its first vintage in 1839
Sylvia France:
1839, did they get through prohibition?
Nancy May:
Oh, smooth sailing, darling.
Nancy May:
I'm gonna use this darling thing - Because I've got this Boston hook going on.
Nancy May:
But they made it through with, guess what?
Sylvia France:
What?
Nancy May:
Church wine.
Nancy May:
They made it to the altar time and time again.
Nancy May:
Lot of drinking on those altars
Sylvia France:
Well, they didn't do that in the Protestant church.
Sylvia France:
I think I need to change religions
Nancy May:
Well, and the church never closed,
Sylvia France:
glasses up then to Thanksgiving at your house
Nancy May:
Ching ching.
Nancy May:
, Now something you can use today.
Nancy May:
If you're a guest this year, text your host one question, "Is the food going home or should I bring
Nancy May:
something to put it in to just make your life a little easier?" I think that's rather presumptuous.
Sylvia France:
And if you're the host, answer before anybody has to ask.
Sylvia France:
Just bring your plastic
Nancy May:
I know what's happening at my house then.
Nancy May:
Because the two of us just can't be the only ones at the table with this argument.
Nancy May:
I say leave the plastic home
Sylvia France:
Well, Miss La-Di-Da would say that.
Sylvia France:
But One survey of Thanksgiving hosts found nine in 10 cook
Sylvia France:
more than the table can eat, and that was on purpose
Nancy May:
And the group behind the survey estimates that 320
Nancy May:
million pounds of Thanksgiving food went into the trash last year.
Nancy May:
Now that's a crime, I have to admit.
Nancy May:
And 40% of it was turkey
Sylvia France:
A little under half of those hosts send the food home with their guest.
Sylvia France:
So a lot of you are like me, and a lot of you are like Nancy
Nancy May:
Which leaves you, the guest, standing in somebody's
Nancy May:
kitchen with no idea which house you're gonna be in.
Nancy May:
But I say just cook enough for everybody
Sylvia France:
At mine, you'd know.
Sylvia France:
When I host, I pack up leftovers into containers myself because
Sylvia France:
I like to make sure somebody has something to take home
Nancy May:
And when it's not in your house?
Sylvia France:
Well, it depends on who's hosting.
Sylvia France:
At my aunt's, it's a buffet and you fill your own plastic or tray.
Sylvia France:
. A lot of hosts put out to-go containers or plastic baggies,
Sylvia France:
and I keep washed ones on hand for anybody who comes without
Nancy May:
Do you bring containers for the leftovers yourself then too?
Sylvia France:
My family does, but I absolutely do not.
Sylvia France:
I am not a leftover fan, and I'm the best cook of the bunch
Nancy May:
Well, I do like leftovers, I have to admit.
Nancy May:
Just own.
Sylvia France:
What's the rule where you grew up?
Nancy May:
Well, in New England, a host offering to
Nancy May:
pack something is normal if they have it and they're offering it.
Nancy May:
A guest asking for it out loud, uh, now that gets noticed
Sylvia France:
And when the host does offer
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: You just say, "Oh, you don't have to do that," and smile sheepishly, bat your eyes.
Sylvia France:
And if she offers a second time, you say, "That's so nice of you, dear
Sylvia France:
Well, that's the only thing you could do
Sylvia France:
take it gracefully even though it might end up in the trash
Nancy May:
Yeah, don't say that.
Nancy May:
we had a few of those, believe me.
Nancy May:
Don't ask about Bob and the salmon mousse.
Nancy May:
That's for another story.
Sylvia France:
will have to hear it.
Sylvia France:
Pull it out.
Sylvia France:
We love Bob stories
Nancy May:
not the salmon mousse.
Nancy May:
But I do like leftovers, especially cold stuffing sandwiches, turkey, cranberry sauce, and mayo.
Nancy May:
I just don't think you should have to hand them out to dinner guests
Sylvia France:
See, the sandwich is where you lost me.
Sylvia France:
The day after turkey sandwich, absolutely not.
Nancy May:
I've been told my sandwiches are bread sandwiches.
Nancy May:
Bread, stuffing, bread, maybe a little bit of turkey, but not much.
Sylvia France:
I could handle that.
Sylvia France:
It's just the mayo and the cranberry sauce Well, I don't even like to eat the food I cook.
Sylvia France:
Not that it doesn't taste great, but by the time I've
Sylvia France:
spent all the effort on it, I am totally done with it
Nancy May:
I get that.
Nancy May:
Too much of the same thing, probably too much tasting to make sure there was enough salt in it.
Nancy May:
But you cook the whole meal , and you don't want any of it?
Nancy May:
I still think that's kind of off
Sylvia France:
None.
Sylvia France:
That's why it all goes out the door in plastic baggies
Nancy May:
Well, we're gonna be coming back to that because somebody did study this
Nancy May:
whole thing about cooking too much and not wanting it
Sylvia France:
And there's a third way that you can do Thanksgiving.
Sylvia France:
And at Bob's parents' house
Nancy May:
Well, that was a Thanksgiving that I had never
Nancy May:
experienced before in my entire life until that first one.
Nancy May:
He called it The Depot, Thanksgiving Depot, that was.
Nancy May:
It was more kinda like an open house.
Nancy May:
Well, not an open house.
Nancy May:
It was an open door with family coming in and out at
Nancy May:
different times, coming and going and coming and going.
Nancy May:
You know, it kinda sounds like that movie, what was it, Blazing
Sylvia France:
but whose family was it?
Nancy May:
Well, it was Bob's dad and his stepmom, so it was a blended family.
Nancy May:
There were seven kids in all,
Sylvia France:
No thank you.
Nancy May:
I gotta get my mouth right.
Nancy May:
You've been having too much of that wine already tonight.
Nancy May:
So did anyone leave with food?
Nancy May:
Nobody took food home.
Nancy May:
Absolutely not
Sylvia France:
Why not?
Sylvia France:
I don't understand
Nancy May:
Barbara had a lot of mouths to feed, so she made sure it was all packed up usually
Nancy May:
before the last person even arrived, then she had enough
Nancy May:
left over for the rest of the week and everybody could eat it
Sylvia France:
When I was a guest at Thanksgiving in Omaha,
Sylvia France:
I don't remember anyone offering leftovers, thank goodness.
Sylvia France:
But when I hosted there, I'm sure everybody went home with something
Nancy May:
I am not surprised, Miss Francie Pants.
Sylvia France:
So if you're the one handing food out,
Sylvia France:
don't assume the other person knows the custom either
Nancy May:
No, the word leftover is younger than you think.
Nancy May:
One food historian says that nobody actually did call it leftovers
Nancy May:
until the end of the 1800s , when kitchens started to get ice boxes
Sylvia France:
What did they call it before that?
Nancy May:
before that it was just plain old food, F-O-O-D.
Nancy May:
Yeah.
Nancy May:
All right, stop snarking at
Nancy May:
Who, me?
Nancy May:
Who, me?
Nancy May:
Never.
Nancy May:
It was tomorrow's meal, And she says 100 years ago, having
Nancy May:
food left over meant your family was, pretty well off
Sylvia France:
so Leftovers were something to show off.
Sylvia France:
I'm not so sure about that
Nancy May:
Well, kind of like your waistline back then too.
Nancy May:
But one woman built a career on it, ruth Berzelheimer.
Nancy May:
I think that's how you pronounce it.
Nancy May:
Don't laugh at me.
Nancy May:
I am laughing at you, sorry
Nancy May:
okay.
Nancy May:
Well, maybe not.
Nancy May:
But she put a cookbook out about it in 1940 and called it 500 Delicious Dishes from Leftovers.
Nancy May:
Mm, I think that's stretching it.
Nancy May:
Like a s- like a
Sylvia France:
I, you know, I don't, I don't think I would've bought it
Nancy May:
No, I don't think I would've either.. But the same historian calls her , , one of
Nancy May:
the best-selling cookbook authors the country ever had, , and hardly anybody knows this woman's name now
Sylvia France:
So tell me about a few of the recipes in this cookbook
Nancy May:
Well, in those years there was ham and banana rolls in cheese sauce.
Nancy May:
Ugh.
Nancy May:
And that's a bestseller?
Nancy May:
I don't think so.
Nancy May:
And get this, even worse, leftover carrots mashed up and shaped, you got it, back to look like carrots.
Nancy May:
Really?
Sylvia France:
That sounds disgusting
Nancy May:
Well, we can agree on that at least.
Nancy May:
Then the country got a little bit richer and leftovers turned into a joke, seriously.
Nancy May:
In the 1960s, cookbooks open- uh, one 1960s cookbook opens with a minister looking at his new wife's
Nancy May:
casserole saying, "He'd bless a good deal… He'd bless a good deal
Nancy May:
over this material befo- He blessed a good deal." Yeah, this is okay.
Nancy May:
"He blessed a good deal or a lot over this meal well before he took this forkful."
Sylvia France:
It's like mystery meat.
Sylvia France:
It sounds like the mystery casserole to me
Nancy May:
Right.
Nancy May:
, and whether you're proud of a packed fridge on a Friday
Nancy May:
or sick of it, somebody's been there well before you
Sylvia France:
So a few things.
Sylvia France:
Thank you for being here, and we're so glad you're listening today
Nancy May:
Yes.
Nancy May:
Maybe you want to sit down for leftovers, but if you
Nancy May:
like this show, follow it and leave us a review.
Nancy May:
go to FamilyFoodStories.com.
Nancy May:
, That's how the next person finds us and pulls up a seat
Sylvia France:
And hello to Carrine and her fiance Robbie in Antwerp, Belgium
Nancy May:
Hello, Corinne.
Nancy May:
Happy wedding Bob and I had Thanksgiving once with a
Nancy May:
couple on the Canadian side of Niagara, Niagara-on-the-Lake.
Nancy May:
Gorgeous area.
Nancy May:
And I asked our Canadian friends what they called Thanksgiving up there
Sylvia France:
And what did he say?
Nancy May:
You're gonna love this one.
Nancy May:
He looked at me as I brought everybody turkey hats so we all had turkeys on our heads.
Sylvia France:
Of course you did
Nancy May:
Canadians thought we were nuts.
Nancy May:
My friend knew better, but he said, "Well, on this side of the border we call it Thursday."
Sylvia France:
I hope you reminded him that Canada has a Thanksgiving Day as well,
Nancy May:
Yes.
Nancy May:
Well, he knew that, but it just wasn't our Thanksgiving.
Nancy May:
But , tell us what you wanna hear about on our next show.
Nancy May:
Because we'd love to know about it, and we read every single one.
Nancy May:
one.
Nancy May:
. You can send us a note on our website at FamilyFoodStories.com
Nancy May:
or in our Facebook group at Family Tree Food Stories
Sylvia France:
You said people needed a dog, and I wonder if
Sylvia France:
you would have brought a doggy bag to B.B. and the Mighty Quinn
Nancy May:
It's too much for a clown, and B well, she'd rather eat the whole turkey.
Nancy May:
That's besides the point.
Nancy May:
But in 1940s when the war was on, pet owners were told to feed their animals table scraps.
Nancy May:
That way they were saving on money, I guess, and doing whatever.
Nancy May:
But restaurants in San Francisco and Seattle started
Nancy May:
handing out waxed paper bags for the bones for dogs
Sylvia France:
It doesn't sound it was really for the dogs, but
Nancy May:
Well, and you gotta be careful about that . We had a dog who got his jaw stuck in
Nancy May:
one of those bone once, . Getting that off was quite the feat
Sylvia France:
See, I was thinking of bone broth when the dog, when I first heard about doggy bags
Nancy May:
Yeah, well, no.
Nancy May:
But at first
Nancy May:
When people got the bags those with dogs, it went to the dogs.
Nancy May:
People with no dog worked it out that it's for, yes, the dog.
Nancy May:
Hmm.
Nancy May:
Then they got them steak to take home.
Nancy May:
That's better than a bone.
Sylvia France:
hopefully had a bone in it.
Sylvia France:
So the name wasn't a joke
Nancy May:
Nope, it wasn't a joke at all.
Nancy May:
It's actually a good cover story.
Nancy May:
One New York steakhouse printed the owner's Scottish terrier right on the bag, and it's one
Nancy May:
of about three places that claim that they started the tradition
Sylvia France:
Can anybody prove who was first?
Sylvia France:
- Nancy May: Nope, not a one.
Sylvia France:
But the manners people, they noticed
Sylvia France:
They did.
Sylvia France:
Newspaper advice columns were still getting letters about it into the 1970s.
Sylvia France:
Is it all right to ask for a doggy bag if you don't own a dog?
Sylvia France:
I
Nancy May:
think so, but what did the column say?
Sylvia France:
One ruled the bags were for bones going home to pets and that should be kept to that
Nancy May:
For the pets and not you?
Nancy May:
Mm, I think it's okay to lie.
Sylvia France:
Bones are exactly what I ask a host for once
Nancy May:
You ask somebody for the bones?
Nancy May:
Sylvia
Sylvia France:
I did, and I don't regret it a bit.
Sylvia France:
I was a guest at a Cuban Thanksgiving in West Tampa.
Sylvia France:
That part of town grew up around the cigar factories in the 1890s, and most of the
Sylvia France:
people who came to work for them were Cuban and Spanish
Nancy May:
So, mm, Cuban Thanksgiving,.
Nancy May:
I'm guessing it wasn't Indians and Pilgrims.
Nancy May:
So what was on that table?
Sylvia France:
Well, this one, it was a boatload of people.
Sylvia France:
So they had three turkeys, one fried, the others baked with stuffing.
Sylvia France:
The festivities, as you can imagine, were loud, and they were on Cuban time, so that's at least
Sylvia France:
45 minutes late, and more food than humanly possible, and they made this delicious homemade sangria
Nancy May:
So after how many sangrias you wanted the bones?
Nancy May:
. Sylvia France: I about freaked out when they were throwing the skin and the bones in the garbage.
Nancy May:
I'm like, "Stop." You know, I'm broth queen, so I love
Nancy May:
the bones and the skin for my world-famous broth.
Nancy May:
They thought it was strange, they laughed, and then of course they packed it up for me
Nancy May:
that was a good host.
Nancy May:
So how was the broth though?
Sylvia France:
It was amazing . If there's something on the table you want,
Sylvia France:
the carcass is the leftover nobody will fight for
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: That I will agree about.
Sylvia France:
, Although Bob makes a pretty mean turkey soup
Sylvia France:
Well, I know how good you are at bone broth, so it kinda scares bit.
Nancy May:
Soup, not bone broth.
Nancy May:
Very different
Sylvia France:
The bones weren't actually what I wanted most from the table, but I forgot to ask
Nancy May:
So , three turkeys that meant there were three wishbones.
Nancy May:
That's the one leftover that most people fight over on purpose.
Nancy May:
I would have fought over that one for sure
Sylvia France:
Well, did you know you have to dry it out first or it won't snap?
Nancy May:
Yep.
Nancy May:
We used to tie them up in ribbons and hang them up for the next year.
Nancy May:
But the Turkey Hotline people say to pull it out before the bird
Nancy May:
is going into the oven, and then let it dry as long as you can
Sylvia France:
So why do we wish on it?
Nancy May:
Well, the story that everybody tells goes back to the Etruscans and the Romans, of
Nancy May:
course.- And nobody can pin that quite down as to exactly who.
Nancy May:
But
Nancy May:
what's on paper is an old English name, the merry thought.
Nancy May:
Whoever got the longer piece was supposed to get married, not marry, first.
Sylvia France:
Oh, your mind in the gutter yet
Nancy May:
Ah, well,
Sylvia France:
when did it turn into a wish?
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: over here in the States across the pond, the wishbone is an American word.
Sylvia France:
in print by the 1840s and in a lot of the South it's called the pulley bone
Sylvia France:
Not in my family.
Sylvia France:
We just called it the plain old wishbone.
Sylvia France:
If you want the wish this year, you get the bone out early
Sylvia France:
. - Nancy May: So this thing about asking on Thanksgiving used to be a whole custom.
Sylvia France:
Around the 1900s, kids in New York used to put on
Sylvia France:
costumes and masks and went door to door on Thanksgiving
Sylvia France:
On Thanksgiving, not Halloween?
Sylvia France:
That sounds really weird
Nancy May:
Yes, Thanksgiving.
Nancy May:
And they'd say, "Anything for Thanksgiving?" I feel like alms for the poor.
Nancy May:
Not really.
Nancy May:
And people handed over pennies and apples and candies and all sorts of little treats to the kids
Sylvia France:
That sounds like trick-or-treating to me
Nancy May:
Right.
Nancy May:
That's what I thought too.
Nancy May:
But before there was trick-or-treating, they called the kids the ragamuffins.
Nancy May:
, And one folklorist, , we'll call them fork-loreists, we like that one, argues that
Nancy May:
this is where Halloween got the idea of trick-or-treat
Nancy May:
… Sylvia France: So what would happen if you didn't give them anything?
Nancy May:
One New York paper warned that you'd get swatted with a sock full of flour
Nancy May:
by these hooligans
Sylvia France:
And so what happened to this custom?
Nancy May:
The schools apparently decided it was considered begging.
Nancy May:
Please, sir, may I have another?
Nancy May:
That kind of sounds like a Thanksgiving thing, right?
Sylvia France:
Right
Nancy May:
Christmas.
Nancy May:
But in the 1950s, the custom had to move to October
Sylvia France:
Somebody in your family may have
Sylvia France:
knocked on a stranger's door for Thanksgiving candy.
Sylvia France:
Asking was the custom until somebody called it begging.
Nancy May:
My Dad must have done that
Sylvia France:
Wouldn't it be interesting to see him throw a sack of flour?
Nancy May:
yeah- I'm not gonna tell you the story that he told
Nancy May:
me about the cat one time as a kid but that wasn't good.
Nancy May:
It'll totally blow his nice personality story.
Nancy May:
But
Nancy May:
there's one dish I always assign at Thanksgiving or
Nancy May:
Christmas because I really don't like making cranberry sauce
Sylvia France:
I understand that other couple's bringing the cranberry sauce this year.
Sylvia France:
So think about your own table.
Sylvia France:
A guest brings the cranberry sauce, and whose leftovers are whose?
Nancy May:
Well, that one is for Miss Manners, and the etiquette writers had a rule., if it's
Nancy May:
still in the dish that you carried it in, it goes home with you.
Nancy May:
But once it's in the host bowl, it stays put
Sylvia France:
Oh, I want to know about this one.
Sylvia France:
What about a bottle of wine I bring?
Nancy May:
You're not getting it from my clutches.
Nancy May:
But honestly, that's a gift.
Nancy May:
. One etiquette teacher puts it this way: "Once you hand it over, it belongs to the host.
Nancy May:
Although, you know, I'd ask if you want to open it
Sylvia France:
Only if it's chilled.
Sylvia France:
So , for a potluck, I'd bring it in something disposable, my dish.
Sylvia France:
the wine?
Sylvia France:
I can bring a box of wine.
Sylvia France:
- For a potluck, I usually bring a dish in something disposable.
Sylvia France:
And you know I'm bringing my food to your house in aluminum pans
Nancy May:
I know, you've already warned me.
Nancy May:
That's okay
Sylvia France:
Well, it's only because I'm going to cook it at your place so it's nice and
Sylvia France:
warm and bubbly when I get there rather than the hour drive.
Nancy May:
I got it
Nancy May:
. Sylvia France: So I have another question for you.
Nancy May:
If you bring something in an aluminum pan, who is in charge of making it beautimous?
Nancy May:
Ah., I've got that answer for you after the break
Nancy May:
Okay.
Nancy May:
So you bring the dish, and it's gotta look pretty,
Nancy May:
'cause it's not gonna look pretty in that aluminum pan.
Nancy May:
I tell you, I guarantee that for sure.
Nancy May:
So my solution is you bring the dish, you've done the work, it's my job to do the
Nancy May:
work to make it absolutely spectacular looking, darling
Sylvia France:
You know?
Sylvia France:
And that works for me.
Sylvia France:
It's all yours
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: Now if you're not wanting your own cooking, researchers at Carnegie Mellon
Sylvia France:
had people imagine eating a food one piece after another 30 times.
Sylvia France:
I can't imagine doing that anyway,
Sylvia France:
That's torture.
Sylvia France:
Imagine it and not eating it 30 times
Nancy May:
Not one bite.
Nancy May:
Then they put the real thing in front of them and , well,
Nancy May:
they ate less of it than anybody else in the room
Sylvia France:
So the time I've cooked it, I've eaten it in my head so many times and tasted it too
Nancy May:
I think you need to go outside and get some air while you're cooking , If
Nancy May:
you're coming to my house, you're eating, especially if you made it.
Nancy May:
But that's one way to read it.
Nancy May:
However, nobody's actually tested the cooks to see if it's true.
Nancy May:
So let's just call it a hunch
Sylvia France:
I'll take a hunch.
Sylvia France:
And if you're the cook this year and you can't face the turkey on
Sylvia France:
Friday, you're in good company, and just give it away to your friends
Nancy May:
I don't know., If the turkey's cooking in
Nancy May:
my house, I'm eating the skin before anybody else.
Sylvia France:
Well, it's gonna be lovely since mine's are a lot, so you have lots of crispy skin
Nancy May:
good.
Nancy May:
. But whoever ends up with the food, - you've got a clock to manage.
Nancy May:
The government's rule is - two hours to get it into the fridge once it's off the heat
Sylvia France:
And once it's there in the fridge
Nancy May:
Four days.
Nancy May:
, That seems like an awfully short time, especially if there's a lot of leftovers.
Nancy May:
But Thanksgiving leftovers are good through Monday, , then
Nancy May:
you freeze them or just let them go to the dogs
Sylvia France:
Well, i'm driving an hour to your house with the dinner.
Sylvia France:
It's gonna be chilled in coolers and ready to cook.
Sylvia France:
Just pop it in the oven
Nancy May:
Oh, give me plenty of warning so I know when to expect you.
Nancy May:
But if your food rides in a car in either direction, make sure you do pack a cooler like Sylvia
Sylvia France:
Well, we still haven't
Sylvia France:
settled the argument of the containers for leftovers
Nancy May:
No.
Nancy May:
That's for sure.
Nancy May:
But the people who write the, yeah, but people who write the manners column also have their solution.
Nancy May:
They say the host decides where those leftovers go
Sylvia France:
Oh, according to who?
Nancy May:
Well, according to Southern Living for one, and
Nancy May:
since we're both down South and I'm an adopted Southerner, well,
Sylvia France:
You're trying
Nancy May:
Yes, I'm trying.
Nancy May:
- their answer to whether you should take the leftovers
Nancy May:
home from a party is, in a word, nope, nada, no way
Sylvia France:
Well, I respectfully disagree
Sylvia France:
. Nancy May: They also say that you shouldn't load up on
Sylvia France:
other guests' dishes who are brought in on the way out.
Sylvia France:
Their exact words are, "Listen, darlin', you're not a raccoon."
Sylvia France:
Well, i'm not a raccoon either.
Sylvia France:
Maybe that's why I don't take them home
Nancy May:
Well, they do leave a little crack in that door though.
Nancy May:
At a family member's house or at a close friend's house they say the rule may not always apply
Sylvia France:
Well, that's my family's table, , and everybody at it brought a dish.
Sylvia France:
I draw the line using paper plates, which commonly used at my family gatherings.
Sylvia France:
So when I host, it's real dishes, glasses, forks, and knives, and they go home with the leftovers
Nancy May:
I agree with you there.
Nancy May:
In fact, Grandma's dishes come out at Thanksgiving and just for dinner
Nancy May:
when we have guests anyway, except the other day when I made pizza.
Nancy May:
Okay, but it's still not paper plates in our house
Sylvia France:
I totally agree.
Sylvia France:
And I had 13 people in my house, and I did dishes for three days, and it was well worth it
Nancy May:
That's okay.
Nancy May:
That's what grandma's dishes are for, as I say.
Nancy May:
But you said the bones weren't what you wanted the most from that Cuban Thanksgiving
Nancy May:
.. Sylvia France: They weren't.
Nancy May:
I'm so glad I had them though.
Nancy May:
But what I really wanted was the sangria recipe, and I never asked for it.
Nancy May:
I think maybe I had too many glasses.
Nancy May:
gosh.
Nancy May:
So I'd be upset with that one, too.
Nancy May:
But why didn't you ask?
Nancy May:
You're not shy
Sylvia France:
I know.
Sylvia France:
It just didn't seem appropriate, especially as I
Sylvia France:
was walking out with bags of carcasses of their turkeys.
Nancy May:
I can picture that now.
Nancy May:
Oh my God.
Nancy May:
That and trying to pull out the wine at the same time.
Nancy May:
Yeah,
Nancy May:
No, Yeah.- So were you able to do anything about it and get that recipe eventually?
Sylvia France:
Yes, I searched for it afterwards.
Sylvia France:
Some recipes put rum in it with wine and some use brandy and no rum at all.
Sylvia France:
One calls for a whole bottle of coconut rum
Nancy May:
All right.
Nancy May:
I know you're not a coconut fan, but could that be the recipe that you actually used?
Sylvia France:
Absolutely not.
Sylvia France:
Not a zippo.
Sylvia France:
I don't even like the smell of suntan lotion with coconut or shampoo.
Sylvia France:
Mm-mm.
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: Then which one did the family make?
Sylvia France:
Do you know?
Sylvia France:
I still don't know exactly, but my guess it's the one with brandy.
Sylvia France:
When I made the next time, it tasted closest to at least what I remembered
Sylvia France:
, Nancy May: If it's anything like Bob's Cherry Bounce, pour me a glass
Sylvia France:
Or two
Sylvia France:
whatever you decide about the turkey, don't do what I did.
Sylvia France:
Ask for the recipe before you leave that house on Thursday
Nancy May:
So then the question is really how do you ask
Nancy May:
without turning it into an inquisition or an interview?
Sylvia France:
Well, you don't ask for the recipe at first.
Sylvia France:
You pick one dish while it's still on the table and ask the cook, "So where did you
Sylvia France:
learn this recipe? Who made this when you were little?"
Nancy May:
that gets you a story, not a recipe though
Sylvia France:
Exactly.
Sylvia France:
The recipe comes later in the kitchen where it's quiet.
Sylvia France:
Ask how they made it and record your answer on the phone or write it in our book
Nancy May:
This actually sounds like a great idea, especially
Nancy May:
in our book, but I like the idea of getting the story.
Nancy May:
But how many people do you know really ask those kind of questions at Thanksgiving?
Sylvia France:
Well, there's a whole project for it.
Sylvia France:
. Since 2015, StoryCorps has asked people to record an older relative at Thanksgiving on a phone app
Nancy May:
That's interesting.
Nancy May:
I haven't heard about that one before.
Nancy May:
But where do all those recordings go?
Sylvia France:
They go into an archive at the Library of Congress.
Sylvia France:
Hundreds and thousands of people have done it, and I think it's a great idea
Nancy May:
That's actually fabulous, quite frankly.
Nancy May:
I wish I had known about this , when mom and dad were still around.
Nancy May:
But the really cool thing is that your grandmother's
Nancy May:
stuffing recipe could end up in the Library of Congress.
Nancy May:
Or just skip the app altogether and write the recipe in our book, My Family Tree Food and Stories, which
Nancy May:
you can get on Amazon by going to the link at FamilyFoodStories.com.
Nancy May:
It's a link at the top that says book
Sylvia France:
Well, I understand that would have
Sylvia France:
worked well for your dad who didn't like his voice recorded
Nancy May:
You're right, unfortunately
Sylvia France:
But what's most important is you make sure that you have the cook's name on it
Nancy May:
I agree, because you gotta know where the origin story was of anything.
Nancy May:
But five things before we go, and five things that you can take with you after this show.
Nancy May:
One, if you're a guest, ask before bringing the containers for the leftovers.
Nancy May:
Please don't seem like a low-class mooch.
Nancy May:
Sorry, Sylvia.
Sylvia France:
Oh, well.
Sylvia France:
You still love me
Nancy May:
I do.
Nancy May:
But if you're hosting, put that plan in the invitation
Nancy May:
and set the containers out if you want the food to leave
Nancy May:
, Sylvia France: Two, pick one dish and ask its cook one question at the table.
Nancy May:
Record the rest later in the kitchen or just write it down in our book
Nancy May:
Three is the clock.
Nancy May:
. That's kind of important.
Nancy May:
Food goes in the fridge within two hours, and it's finished by Monday,
Nancy May:
and if you're taking it home in the car, it rides in the cooler
Sylvia France:
Four, if you want something off that table, ask for it.
Sylvia France:
Start with the
Sylvia France:
carcass because nobody will fight you for it.
Nancy May:
Yeah, no bones about it.
Nancy May:
Ha ha.
Nancy May:
And five
Sylvia France:
Argue about the turkey all you want.
Sylvia France:
Just don't leave the table without a recipe for something that you ate there.
Sylvia France:
It's a memory
Nancy May:
And it's something that you love.
Nancy May:
Get that story.
Nancy May:
So I think we need to do at least maybe one, two, or three more glasses up, Sylvia.
Nancy May:
What do you say?
Sylvia France:
Oh, absolutely.
Sylvia France:
Count me in.
Sylvia France:
to that sangria, whatever was in it, go ask your cook
Nancy May:
And . , We're planning our winter holiday series, so
Nancy May:
next time there's a lot more on the table than leftovers for sure
Sylvia France:
So happy cooking and happy experimenting.
Sylvia France:
And did I tell you that I'm going to bring some of the sauerkraut that I just made?
Sylvia France:
My latest experiment
Nancy May:
Does it go with wine?
Nancy May:
I think we'll have to test that one.
Sylvia France:
I'll have to do my world famous Reubens I keep talking about
Nancy May:
Yeah, no, I'll stick with the Brotherhood Spiced Wine.
Nancy May:
Goodbye.